the difference is real
Every cookie that leaves our kitchen is made like I'm serving it to my own family. There’s no formal rule behind it—just care, attention, and a little love baked into every batch.
Caitlyn Dao
NEW ARRIVAL
The "Take Some With You"Box
Oh Fer Cute! Box
Ten cookies, ten reasons to smile. A hand-curated tasting box with all 7 flavors, baked fresh for your pickup date.
🍪 1 Chocolate Chip · 1 Sugar Drop · 1 Oreo-Stuffed · 1 Salted Caramel · 2 S'mores · 2 Peanut Butter · 2 Oatmeal Raisin
Perfect for gifting, sharing, or treating yourself to a little bit of everything. 🎁
$25.00
Made fresh
for your pickup date
per BOX
1. Fan Favorite
Classic
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Warm, nostalgic, and irresistibly indulgent! Our classic chocolate chip cookies are everything a cookie should be. Each batch is made from scratch with rich, buttery dough, generously studded with melty chocolate chips, and baked to golden perfection. The edges are perfectly crisp while the centers stay soft, chewy, and just a little gooey.
$3.50
Made fresh
for your pickup date
per cookie
2. THE CLASSIC
Timeless
Peanut Butter Cookies
Soft, rich peanut butter cookies baked to golden perfection with a tender, melt-in-your-mouth center and lightly crisp edges. Each cookie is packed with bold, nutty flavor and finished with the classic crisscross top for that homemade touch.
$3.50
Made fresh
for your pickup date
per 2 cookies
3. cozy
Nostalgic
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Soft and hearty oatmeal raisin cookies baked with wholesome oats, plump raisins, toasted walnuts, and warm hints of cinnamon. Golden on the outside with a chewy, comforting center, each bite is perfectly balanced with just the right touch of sweetness and spice.
$3.50
Made fresh
for your pickup date
per 2 cookies
4. Irrisistable
Wholesome
Sugar Cookies
Soft, tender sugar drop cookies baked to a light golden finish with a delicate sweetness in every bite. Pillowy and buttery with a gently crisp edge, they’re a simple, comforting treat that melts in your mouth. A timeless bakery favorite made for everyday indulgence.
$3.00
per cookie
Made fresh
for your pickup date
5. Gourmet
Decadent
Oreo-Stuffed Cookies
Thick, soft-baked gourmet cookies packed with rich chocolate flavor and stuffed with a whole Oreo center for the ultimate cookies-and-cream experience. Each bite is gooey, indulgent, and loaded with crushed Oreo pieces and melty chocolate goodness. A decadent, bakery-style treat made to satisfy every sweet craving.
$5.50
Made fresh
for your pickup date
per cookie
6. Luxurious
Irresistable
Salted Caramel Cookies
Soft-baked gourmet cookies filled with rich, buttery caramel and finished with a touch of flaky sea salt for the perfect sweet-and-salty balance. A decadent, handcrafted treat made for true caramel lovers.
$4.50
per cookie
Made fresh
for your pickup date
7. Limited Drop
Summer Seasonal
S'mores Cookie
Soft-baked summer seasonal s’mores cookies packed with gooey marshmallow, rich chocolate, and buttery graham cracker pieces. Each cookie is thick, chewy, and slightly toasted at the edges for that classic campfire-inspired flavor.
$4.50
Made fresh
for your pickup date
per cookie
What Fargo-Moorhead says
Oh Fer Cute!
For real though.
"Ordered two dozen peanut butter cookies for my son's class party and every single one was gone in five minutes. The teacher asked me for the bakery's number. Ten out of ten."
Frankie B.
"Ordered two dozen peanut butter cookies for my son's class party and every single one was gone in five minutes. The teacher asked me for the bakery's number. Ten out of ten."
Frankie B.
"Got a 3-dozen bundle for a baby shower — hit of the entire party. Beautiful, delicious, and Caitlyn was so easy to work with. Already planning my next order."
Jessica R.
Follow Along